Researchers know the built environment affects behavior. In healthcare environments, with increased stress and high stakes, the design of the built environment can have a significant impact on safety, specifically on infection prevention. Risk of infection can be reduced through many design factors, including materials used in building construction, location of hand sanitizer dispensers, and knowledge of and access to personal protective equipment (PPE). 

At the SimTigrate Design Lab, we have studied the effects of the built environment on infection prevention and safety in many settings. Recently, we have researched the impact of the built environment on safety while doffing personal protective equipment in biocontainment units (BCU).

Floor plan of a decontamination area with labeled zones: doffing, clean, and trained observer zones. Key areas include sinks, buckets, and a shower.

CHOA SCU/EUHM BCU

Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta (CHOA) Special Care Unit (SCU)/ Emory University Hospital Midtown (EUHM) Mother-Baby Biocontainment Unit (BCU)

Keywords: Implementations, Design Review, Biocontainment Unit (BCU)
Methods: Mock-Up Simulation, Functional Scenario Analysis
 

The SimTigrate Design Center’s ultimate goal is the implementation of our research findings in real-world scenarios. As part of this effort, we provide our expertise and knowledge of evidence to advise the design of BCUs in local Atlanta building projects, including Children's Healthcare of Atlanta (CHOA) and Emory University Hospital Midtown (EUHM). 
For the CHOA Special Care Unit, the SimTigrate team collaborated with CHoA in mock-up simulations to observe and document the space utilization, and conduct Functional Scenario Analysis to provide systematic evaluation and feedback on proposed design options and optimize the final design solution for the SCU.
For the EUHM Mother-Baby BCU, the SimTigrate team collaborated with researchers from Pacific Northwest National Laboratory to evaluate the design for biocontainment use, the unit layout for the simulation and training lab, as well as the overall lighting quality.

Prevention Epicenter of Emory and Collaborating Healthcare Facilities (PEACH)

The PEACH Project

Prevention Epicenter of Emory and Atlanta Consortium Hospitals

Keywords: Infection Control, Built Environment, PPE Doffing Safety
Methods: Simulations
 

The study objective is to identify ways that the built environment may support or disrupt safe doffing of personal protective equipment (PPE) in biocontainment units (BCU). We observed interactions between healthcare workers (HCWs) and the built environment during 41 simulated PPE donning and doffing exercises, conducted across the BCUs of four Ebola treatment facilities and one high-fidelity BCU mockup. In total, 64 participants took part in this study, including 41 doffing HCWs and 15 trained observers (TOs).

In each facility, we observed how the physical environment influences risky behaviors by the HCW. The environmental design impeded communication between TOs and HCWs because of limited window size or visual obstructions with louvers, which allowed unobserved errors. The size and configuration of the doffing area impacted HCW adherence to protocol, and the lack of clear demarcation of zones resulted in HCWs inadvertently leaving the doffing area and stepping back into the contaminated areas. Lack of a standard location for items resulted in equipment and supplies frequently shifting positions. Finally, different solutions for maintaining balance while removing shoe covers (ie, chair, hand grips, and step stool) had variable success. We identified the 5 key requirements that doffing areas must achieve to support safe doffing of PPE, and we developed a matrix of proposed design strategies that can be implemented to meet those requirements. In conclusion, simple, low-cost environmental design interventions can provide structure to support and improve HCW safety in BCUs. These interventions should be implemented in both current and future BCUs.
 

Access full publication: 
Design Strategies for Biocontainment Units: Creating Safer Environments
English Version | Korean Version | Portuguese Version | Farsi Version | Chinese Version

Serious Communicable Disease Unit (SCDU)

Serious Communicable Disease Unit (SCDU)

Keywords: Patient Experience, Biocontainment Unit (BCU)
Methods: Interview
 

The project aims to understand the Ebola patients’ experience living in a BCU and learn how the built environment impacted that experience. Our team had the opportunity to interview all 4 Ebola patients treated at Emory University Hospital in 2014 and 2 of the nurses who cared for them about the care experience. This qualitative study looks at the unique needs of patients with highly infectious diseases treated in BCUs, their experiences while held in isolation, and how those needs change over the course of their stay. This study has given us great insight into the patient’s perspective and how the patient room can be designed to improve their experience while in isolation. Through this project, SimTigrate became the first research lab to interview patients who were treated for Ebola in the United States.

Hand Hygiene Compliance Projects

Conceptual framework between visibility and accessibility of hand hygiene stations and fatigue during the COVID-19 pandemic

Visibility and Accessibility of Hand Hygiene Stations

Hand Hygiene Compliance Projects 01

Visibility and Accessibility of Hand Hygiene Stations and Fatigue among Nurses Working in Long-term Care (LTC) during the COVID-19 Pandemic

Keywords: Long-term care (LTC), COVID-19, Nurses
Methods: National Survey
 

This cross-sectional study examined how visibility and accessibility of hand hygiene stations (HHS) in long-term care (LTC) settings related to nurse fatigue during the COVID-19 pandemic. Using an online survey of LTC nurses between June 2020 and January 2021, the researchers found that a large majority of nurses (over 78 %) reported moderate to very severe fatigue. After controlling for factors like demographics, guilt about leaving family or patients, workplace support, and confidence in the future of LTC, nurses who perceived fewer or less accessible hand hygiene stations in their work environment were significantly more likely to report higher fatigue levels compared with those who felt HHS were adequate. The authors suggest that improving the visibility and accessibility of infection-control infrastructure, like hand hygiene stations, could help mitigate nurse fatigue in LTC environments during public health crises.

Overlay observed HH occurrences with space syntax heatmap

Post-occupancy Evaluations of Healthcare Facilities

Hand Hygiene Compliance Projects 02

Keywords: Hand Hygiene, Infection Control, Nursing Unit Typology, Space Syntax, Visibility
Methods: Comparative Study, Statistical Analysis
 

This study compared two hospital nursing units to examine how the visibility and accessibility of hand sanitizer dispensers affects healthcare workers’ hand hygiene behavior. The unit where dispensers were more visible and easier to reach had significantly more hand hygiene activity, even though it had fewer dispensers per bed. This shows that nursing unit layout and design directly influence healthcare workers’ behavior and patient safety. Designing spaces where hand sanitizer is clearly visible and integrated into daily workflows can help improve hand hygiene and reduce the risk of infections.

HAND HYGIENE COMPLIANCE DATA

Collaborative Computational Design to Improve Hand Hygiene

Hand Hygiene Compliance Projects 03

Improving Hand Hygiene Compliance through Collaborative Computational Design

Keywords: -
Methods: Computational Scenario Planning, Fuzzy Cognitive Mapping, Machine Learning
 

Hand sanitization by healthcare staff remains one of the most effective ways for controlling infection in healthcare settings. However, predicting faithful adherence to Hand Hygiene Compliance (HHC) is difficult in complex environments such as inpatient hospital settings. The main challenge is understanding how different components of human and built systems interact to achieve specific goals, such as HHC at the critical moments of care delivery. The aim of this explorative study was to evaluate how Human Factors-derived visual salience cues and proximity-compatibility principles might be used in the design of healthcare spaces to support nurse moments of HHC through increased perceived behavioral control and intention. 

The investigative team used a Collaborative Computational Scenario Planning (CCSP) Model approach to determine the integrative effects of reinforcing and detracting operational and environmental factors on discrete moments of HHC behavior. Supervised Machine Learning analysis was conducted on data collected by a large academic medical center that included HHC observance in clinical staff spanning from 2017 to 2021 in two inpatient hospital units. The probabilistic outcomes of unit-based HHC observance likelihood were used to compute Fuzzy Cognitive Model Edge Probabilities between Hand Hygiene (HH) cues and detected HHC at key moments. Hospital infection control experts were then engaged to identify the weight of various reinforcing and detracting operational and environmental factors contributing to HHC observance. Combining the quantitative and qualitative methods, allowed the team to then develop integrative CCSP models, which facilitated predictive insight into the development of targeted environmental improvements that might contribute to HHC control and intention to support safer patient care.

Image credit: Photographed by Hui Cai, Designed by Cannon Design

Questions?

 
If you can't find the information you were looking for, we'll get you to the right place.
Contact Us